Amazon Quits Accepting Reader Reviews of Unverified Book Purchases
Amazon Reader Reviews Only Allowed when Book is Purchased from Amazon.

News Flash:

Last month Amazon quit accepting reader reviews for unverified purchases. You may have seen this message when you tried to upload a review of a galley or a borrowed book.

“Amazon has noticed unusual reviewing activity on this product. Due to this activity, we have limited this product to verified purchase reviews.”

The above message appeared right after I clicked “Write a customer review.” from this listing.

Who knows how long Amazon will persist with this behavior, but right now, it means a sea change for our industry. Why? Because Amazon reviews have historically been significant in driving a book’s sales and now their reviews are harder to get.

If you’ve been publishing your books for a while, you know that Amazon has gone on review jags like this before. In the past, they have banned specific reviewers. They have deleted reviews after they’ve been posted. They’ve accused authors of soliciting fraudulent reviews.

Algorithms don’t always get it right. Just because it looks like a connection may exist between reviewer and author, doesn’t mean there is one, and even if there is, that doesn’t mean an author has influenced the review.

Going forward, I will ask the readers who review my clients’ books to post their remarks to Goodreads, BookBub, and their blog since most of them review from egalleys. Do you plan to redirect where you upload your reviews as a result of this ban on reviews from galleys, borrowed books, and book purchased elsewhere?

To my view, this vendor’s behavior hurts them as much as it hurts authors and reviewers. If they think this will encourage people to purchase books through them, I think they’re mistaken. Do you? Have you ever been banned by Amazon as a reviewer? Have they ever limited reviews for a book you’ve published? Where do you buy your books?

Please drop a comment below with your feedback on Amazon’s new limits on reader reviews.

You May Also Enjoy…

Ten Questions to Develop Your 2022 Writing Goals

Ten Questions to Develop Your 2022 Writing Goals

Ten Questions To Develop Your Writing Goals Answering the ten questions below will help you develop your writing goals. Are the questions a definitive list of what you want to ask yourself? No. Are the questions going to change your life? No, but they could change...

BookBub Bestseller: How One Author Aced a BookBub Featured Deal

BookBub Bestseller: How One Author Aced a BookBub Featured Deal

Welcome D. B. Borton, serial novelist and 2021 BookBub bestseller who aced a BookBub Featured Deal. Tell us how you did it!  Q. Can you give us a brief history of your experience with BookBub? A. I had tried several times for a Featured Deal at BookBub and been...


  1. Hi, Stephanie, I had the same response from Amazon concerning reviews. On a couple of occasions, they refused to published a review with the comment that I knew that person. The reviewer called to complain. I agree with everything you said in the piece you wrote.

    My latest book found a publisher and I hope that I don’t have to run into the same thing with reviewers.

  2. Amazon amazes me— whatever sells books helps them no matter where the reviewer got the book (remember public libraries and direct sales are a great place). It also amazes me that publishers don’t take more of a role in pushing books — they help themselves AND the author where they push.

  3. I am an author. This also hurts us because it excludes books we sell at book signings.

  4. Always good to hear from you, Joan.

  5. Always enjoy your remarks, Nancy.

  6. Yes, Jim, you mention yet another purchasing option that Amazon is cutting out for reviews.

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This