Book Reviews—Why Free Reviews are Best and Paid Reviews are Problematic
Paid Book Review Houses

    Paid Book Review Houses

    When I entered the publishing industry 15 years ago, almost no one paid for book reviews. Websites that offered paid book reviews were marketing to authors who either didn’t know how to request a standard review or weren’t eligible to be reviewed through existing channels. As independent publishing progressed over the years, standard review houses like Publishers Weekly and Kirkus realized they were leaving money on the table by not offering a review stream to indie authors. This realization led to the birth of Kirkus Indie in 2005 and BookLife in 2014 from Publishers Weekly.

    It could easily be argued that traditional publishing spawned the paid review stream by barring indie authors from being reviewed by ALA Booklist, Publishers Weekly, Library Journal and Kirkus. If this is true, then these four were simply late for their own capitalistic party.

    One exception among The Big Five standard review houses is Shelf Awareness, which has always accepted both indie and traditionally published books for free review consideration. From my own experience, it seems as if Shelf Awareness assigns more galleys for review consideration than other review houses. However, their reviewers aren’t required to turn in opinions on every galley they receive.

    Moving in the opposite direction, Foreword Reviews, which accepts indie published and university press releases, began offering free reviews after starting out with paid Clarion Reviews. Today Foreword offers almost a two-for-one bundle with Clarion and BlueInk Reviews as their “fee-for-review” option. With all the advertising they sell in their gorgeous full color magazine, the Sutherlands must be making more money than ever.

    In conclusion, let me say that I will never go along with paid reviews as a standard in our industry. Once money is exchanged, the opinion is bought and sold, which taints its quality and colors its neutrality.

    What do YOU think about the monetization of book reviews? Let me hear from you! Drop your comment below.

    You May Also Enjoy…

    Amazon Quits Accepting Reader Reviews of Unverified Book Purchases

    Amazon Quits Accepting Reader Reviews of Unverified Book Purchases

    News Flash: Last month Amazon quit accepting reader reviews for unverified purchases. You may have seen this message when you tried to upload a review of a galley or a borrowed book. "Amazon has noticed unusual reviewing activity on this product. Due to this activity,...

    BookBub Bestseller: How One Author Aced a BookBub Featured Deal

    BookBub Bestseller: How One Author Aced a BookBub Featured Deal

    Welcome D. B. Borton, serial novelist and 2021 BookBub bestseller who aced a BookBub Featured Deal. Tell us how you did it!  Q. Can you give us a brief history of your experience with BookBub? A. I had tried several times for a Featured Deal at BookBub and been...

    Book PR: How to Optimize a Blog Post      

    Book PR: How to Optimize a Blog Post      

              With the proliferation of social media, you might think that blogging does not matter anymore in book PR. However, blogging still provides unique value because it refreshes your keywords to Google. In my book pr work, I have found that writers resist...

    4 Comments

    1. When I starting writing book reviews for various companies I was paid a nominal fee for my unbiased review. When companies started charging authors for reviews, my nominal fee remained the same as the companies received what I felt was outrageous fees from the authors.

      As a believer that writers should help other writers I began doing free reviews on my blog. I was bombarded with books. As much as I wanted to help others, my own writing time suffered.

      To remedy this I devised a unique format to help others without hurting myself in the process. I added social media promotion to authors with the review and accept books only with a donation from the author, who determines what that amount will be from their budget. Books are reviewed in the order received, and all reviews are done independent from the amount received around my own writing.

      Yes, some authors send even less than the nominal amount than the companies paid me, but overall since I’ve been doing this most authors appreciate my efforts and are fair with their donation amounts.

    2. I’m unaware of a useful paid reviewer for a business book

    3. Thanks for sharing what it’s like from the reviewer side, Angie, by payment from the review house and optional donation from the author.

    4. Thanks for sharing your opinion about reviews for business books, Greg.

    Submit a Comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Pin It on Pinterest

    Share This